Has anyone done a smallpdf vs ilovepdf vs pdf2go comparison for merging files?

I need to combine a bunch of scanned receipts into one PDF for reimbursement, and the size limit on the upload portal is tripping me up. Has anyone actually compared how these three services handle merging?

Honestly, ilovepdf usually gives me the smallest file size when combining vendor invoices. I would just merge them there first and run it through their compress tool right after if the portal limit still gives you trouble.

I have found the merging itself is fairly similar; the important differences are the compression settings and whether the scans remain readable. I would test the same sample in each, check the final file size and legibility, then use the strongest compression that still preserves totals and dates. Since receipts contain personal data, I would use an offline PDF tool if the portal allows it.

I learned the hard way that some mergers bloat the size so now I just use ilovepdf on my tablet, fwiw. Haven’t tried pdf2go much. What device are you on?

Yeah the size limits are annoying, especially with scanned receipts since those get bloated fast. I haven’t done a real side by side but I’d check if your scanner app can export smaller/grayscale images before merging, that usually helps more than which merge tool you pick. Also keep the original scans somewhere just in case the merged file gets rejected and you need to redo it.

I had the same issue with our expense portal rejecting huge receipt files. Instead of using those upload sites, I just paste the receipt images into a blank Word document, resize them, and save it as a PDF. That usually keeps the file size small enough to get through without any fuss.

@clumsy_goblin That’s what I do now for my client invoices. I learned the hard way that running them through ilovepdf compression keeps the text razor sharp while shrinking the file down enough for finicky upload portals.

@samantha_87 the word trick works, i do the same thing with insurance forms at the clinic. one thing that helped me, set the pictures to grayscale and shrink them a bit before saving, that usually drops the size a lot while the totals stay readable.

Are you on Mac or Windows? Merging alone usually won’t shrink scanned receipts much, since the image resolution is what drives the size. I lower scans to 150 dpi or grayscale first, then combine them with Preview on Mac or Print to PDF on Windows. That worked even on my old laptop, and keeps reimbursement details off third-party upload sites.

The size problem is usually the scans, not the merger. Check your scan settings first; 300 dpi color receipts are huge, so rescanning grayscale or 150 dpi often fixes the upload limit. Keep a backup of the originals before merging.

i use ilovepdf the most for merging receips since it usually keeps the size down. tip: merge them all first and then run the final file through their compress tool. avoid scanning in full color if you can help it, i learned the hard way that color just eats up all your space.

Haven’t done a formal three-way test, but receipts have card numbers and personal info, so I’d skip all the upload sites. I merge mine locally in PDFcap: drop the scans in, drag to reorder, hit merge, then compress if it’s still over the portal limit. Keeps everything off random servers, tbh.